Micro Finance Institutions (MFIs), that lend to the bottom of the pyramid, are slowly losing their advantage to growing competition. The share of NBFC-MFIs in the overall microcredit ecosystem has shrunk from 75% to 31% in the past three years. The changing regulatory framework that favours microfinance through the banking channel is also partly to blame. MFI, Bandhan graduated into a universal bank two years ago whereas eight other MFIs converted into a small finance banks recently. This has set the tone of migration of microfinance into the banking sector.
After NBFC-MFIs were permitted to work as business correspondents, banks have upped their ante by picking up stakes in MFIs. IDFC Bank acquired Grama Vidiyal Microfinance whereas Kotak Mahindra Bank acquired BSS Microfinance. NBFCs such as Muthoot Finance and Manappuram Finance picked up majority stakes in Belstar Investment and Finance and Asirvad Microfinance, respectively. Banks became the largest provider of microcredit of Rs 384.9 billion (as of June 2017), with an overall share of 36% as per Microfinance Institutions Network (MFIN). Of this, more than a quarter of the loans are in the form of indirect lending through business correspondent partnerships.
Recently IndusInd Bank entered into an exclusivity agreement to explore the merger proposal with the largest MFI in the country, Bharat Financial Inclusion.
No doubt, the growing dominance of banks in micro-credit is here to stay.
Moreover, banks enjoy a host of advantages over MFIs. Firstly, banks do not have to comply with the regulatory cap of 10% on margins that are applicable to MFIs. Banks armed with multiple products and an assured low-cost deposit base have better access to funds for growth. There are 47 NBFC - MFIs presently registered with MFIN. Barring the top 10 large ones, most of the small NBFC-MFIs find it difficult to raise funds. Notebandi and farm loan waivers have further impacted their business due to a fall in loan repayment rates.
Going ahead, MFIs will have to overhaul their models, either through technological innovation or diversification into new areas, if they have to remain relevant. For example, Delhi-based Satin Care Credit Network is planning to diversify into individual lending in housing whereas MFI, Arohan is contemplating a technological makeover through a tie-up with a payment bank.
Therefore the moat of financial inclusion, around which MFIs came into limelight, needs to be strengthened in the light of growing competitive intensity from banks.
AB Capital is valued at nearly eight times book, L&T Finance holdings is available at five times book. On P/E basis the former is priced at 62 times trailing P/E while L&T finance is at 33 times. AB Capital has been growing at a CAGR of 30 per cent for some time, while L&T Fin holdings is on restructuring mode with 25 per cent growth in the last FY. On the range of businesses under their umbrella, A B Capital has many more than L&T Fin. While the former appears to be increasing the number of businesses it controls, the latter is now focused on just three verticals. While the Birlas are not known to exit businesses that are in trouble, the professional management of L&T Fin is more ruthless and focused on improving ROE. For instance, Birla Sunlife life insurance is steadily losing market share, but its unlikely AB Capital will sell the life insurance business. Same does not apply for L&T Fin.
Comments
Post a Comment